Marillion - Seasons End
On September 25, 1989, "Marillion" released its fifth album, "Seasons End", its first with Steve Hogarth as lead singer.
It was easy to see the change of singers as the end of an era. Since its debut, "Marillion" had built an entire world around Fish's voice and presence, and the albums "Misplaced Childhood" and "Clutching at Straws" had made it one of the leading progressive rock bands of the eighties. After Fish's departure in 1988, the question was not just who could sing the old material. Could the four remaining musicians write new music without listeners searching every bar for the charismatic, commanding frontman who had left?
Yet a new beginning was hidden in that crisis. Steve Rothery, Mark Kelly, Pete Trewavas and Ian Mosley had begun writing the next album while Fish was still in the band. Riffs, transitions and melodies from those early recordings survived the split, but the lyrics and emotional direction had to be born again. Some of those ideas can be heard in demos later included on the expanded edition of "Clutching at Straws". Hearing them makes "Seasons End" even more fascinating. The musical foundation was the same, but an entirely different personality now stood at its center.
Steve Hogarth auditioned in early 1989, arriving from "The Europeans" and "How We Live". He neither sounded nor looked like a replacement for Fish. The band went to write together at a rehearsal space in a former mushroom farm near Brighton. Some material was already waiting there, and Hogarth brought ideas of his own, most notably "Easter". The chemistry developed quickly. The five then moved to Hook End Manor in Oxfordshire and recorded with Nick Davis, who produced the album with them. John Helmer contributed lyrics to some of the songs, and Hogarth brought his own perspective to them.
The album opens with "The King of Sunset Town", nearly eight minutes that refuse to introduce the new singer through an easy hit. Kelly's keyboards open up a reflective space, the bass and drums build momentum gradually, and Steve Rothery's guitar leads the music to its peaks. The voice is different, as is the presence, but Hogarth sounds entirely like a member of the band, not a guest invited to a jam session. Lyrics shaped in part by the suppression of the protests in Tiananmen Square that year give the song's sense of helplessness a sharper meaning.
Then comes "Easter", the song that, to us, marks the birth of the new lineup. It begins with a gentle acoustic guitar and gradually expands without losing its inner quiet. Hogarth wrote it in response to the conflict in Northern Ireland, but sings of the possibility of escaping the cycle of pain. Steve Rothery's solo does not interrupt the story. His guitar says what is hard to put into words, and it sounds so unmistakably like "Marillion".
"The Uninvited Guest" reveals the album's playful, menacing side. The rhythm and chorus are catchy. It is a fine example of "Marillion" forging a new identity without completely losing the old one.
At the heart of the album stands "Seasons End", one of the band's finest moments on this album and beyond. Its starting point is simple and painful: what if winter disappears, and what we take to be the natural order of the world can no longer be taken for granted? The guitar changes colors over the song's eight minutes, the keyboards leave plenty of air, and Hogarth approaches the words with care. As the song gathers force, it becomes a lament for beauty whose value we may only understand after we have lost it. Rothery's solo cuts straight to the heart and deepens that sadness.
"Holloway Girl" also turns away from fantasies of a perfect life. Behind its flowing melody lies the story of Judith Ward, who was imprisoned in Britain after being wrongly convicted of bombings. The song cannot undo the injustice; it gives her a face and a voice. The transition to "Berlin" widens the view from one person to a divided city. This track returns to the band's progressive expanses, with piano, slowly building tension and a guitar that enters at just the right moment. The Berlin Wall fell only weeks after the album's release, a historical detail that makes the song's sense of waiting chilling in retrospect.
After the weight of "Berlin", "After Me" offers a brief, intimate moment. Interestingly, it was absent from the original vinyl edition, but in the CD sequence it gives the ear a rest before the album takes a sharp turn with "Hooks in You". This is rock edging toward heavy, with guitars and a chorus designed to "hook you". It sounds as though it came from another album, even another band, and the group's willingness to include it makes clear that it has no intention of being trapped by its old image.
The album closes with "The Space", which restores the quiet and the sense of space. Parts of it draw on an idea Hogarth had begun developing during his time in "How We Live". The singing starts softly and personally, then the music grows and fills out toward a dramatic ending.
On its release, "Seasons End" reached number seven on the UK albums chart. The album later returned in expanded editions, including a 2023 deluxe edition with a new mix and additional material. But what truly matters can be heard from the opening notes: "Marillion" had survived its change of singer without losing itself. It was a fitting opening to a period of the band's history that deserves more recognition.
For Listening: Spotify, Apple Music
"Face/Off" - Israel's Rock Blog
Comments